Metal roofing has grown rapidly in popularity across Michigan and the U.S., especially as homeowners seek more durable, energy-efficient solutions. But despite its increasing use, misinformation still surrounds this roofing option. Many homeowners hesitate to install metal simply because of outdated or incorrect assumptions. That’s why we’re here to set the record straight.
In this post, we’re breaking down the most common metal roofing myths, replacing them with facts that reflect the realities of today’s high-performing metal roof systems. If you’re weighing roofing materials for a replacement or new build, separating truth from myth is essential to making an informed decision.
Let’s explore what’s fact, what’s fiction, and what makes metal roofing such a smart investment for Michigan homes.
Myth #1: Metal Roofs Are Loud When It Rains
This is probably the most well-known myth—and also one of the most misunderstood. People often assume that rain hitting a metal roof sounds like a tin shed or a metal barn roof. But modern residential metal roofs are installed with insulation, decking, and underlayment, which all work together to absorb sound.
Fact: Metal roofing installed over solid sheathing is no noisier than asphalt shingles. In many cases, the sound is even quieter. Most homes with attic insulation and ventilation won’t hear a noticeable difference.
Myth #2: Metal Roofing Attracts Lightning
Another common myth is that metal roofs increase the risk of lightning strikes. This is understandable—metal is conductive, so the assumption is it “draws” electricity. But that’s not how lightning works.
Fact: Metal roofs do not increase the likelihood of a lightning strike. According to the Metal Construction Association, lightning is drawn to the highest point in an area, regardless of the material. If anything, metal is a safer option because it is non-combustible and will not catch fire if struck. You can read more about lightning safety on the National Weather Service website.
Myth #3: Metal Roofs Rust Easily
Older metal roofing materials were vulnerable to rust, especially if the protective coating wore off. But today’s residential metal roofing systems are built to last and specifically engineered to resist corrosion in all kinds of weather.
Fact: Modern metal roofs are coated with corrosion-resistant finishes like galvalume or zinc-aluminum alloys, then sealed with long-lasting paint. These materials can withstand snow, ice, rain, and even coastal salt exposure for decades without rusting.
In Michigan, where winter weather is a concern, these coatings also prevent damage from freeze-thaw cycles that can break down other roofing materials over time.
Myth #4: Metal Roofing Is Too Expensive
Many homeowners hear “metal roofing” and assume it’s a luxury product that’s far out of reach financially. While it does come with a higher upfront cost than asphalt shingles, that’s only part of the story.
Fact: Metal roofing offers superior long-term value. While initial installation may cost 2–3 times more than asphalt, metal lasts 2–3 times longer (typically 40–70 years), needs fewer repairs, and reduces energy bills.
According to the U.S. Department of Energy, metal roofs reflect solar heat and can lower cooling costs by up to 25%. You can read more about energy-efficient roofing on their Energy Saver resource.
Myth #5: Metal Roofs Are Only for Modern or Industrial Homes
It’s easy to think of standing seam panels on a barn or a sleek, modern build—but metal roofing is available in a wide range of styles, colors, and profiles.
Fact: Today’s metal roofs can mimic the look of wood shakes, clay tiles, or slate, all while offering the benefits of lightweight, durable metal. Whether your home is a craftsman-style bungalow, a colonial, or a farmhouse, there’s a metal roof option to match.
Big Rapids Roofing installs metal systems in both traditional and contemporary homes across Michigan, and our color-matching technology helps preserve the character of your home’s exterior.
Myth #6: Metal Roofs Make Your Home Hotter
This is a common concern—but actually the opposite is true. While bare metal might absorb heat, today’s metal roofing systems use reflective coatings that minimize solar absorption.
Fact: Metal roofing reflects more sunlight than asphalt shingles, which helps keep your attic and home cooler in the summer. This improves comfort, reduces HVAC use, and lowers cooling costs.
Some metal roofs are ENERGY STAR® rated, and many utility companies offer incentives or rebates for installing energy-efficient roofing materials.
Myth #7: Hail Destroys Metal Roofs
Michigan homeowners are right to be concerned about hail—especially in spring and early summer. But many are surprised to learn how well metal roofing holds up under impact.
Fact: Metal roofs are among the most hail-resistant materials on the market. Most products are rated Class 4 impact-resistant, the highest grade available. That means they can withstand 2″ hail with little to no damage.
While no roofing material is 100% hail-proof, metal performs better than asphalt, which can lose granules, crack, or puncture on impact.
Myth #8: Metal Roofing Can’t Be Installed Over Existing Shingles
Some homeowners worry that switching to metal means tearing off the entire existing roof, which can add to labor and disposal costs.
Fact: In many cases, metal roofs can be installed over an existing layer of asphalt shingles, provided the roof is in stable condition and local codes allow it. This saves time and money and reduces waste going to landfills.
At Big Rapids Roofing, we inspect each home thoroughly to determine whether your current roof can serve as a base for a metal system. We never cut corners—but we do find smart ways to minimize unnecessary expense.
Myth #9: Metal Roofs Are Harder to Repair
This one depends on the contractor. Metal roofs require precision and familiarity with panel systems, clips, and sealants. While DIY repairs are not recommended, a trained professional can easily repair or replace sections as needed.
Fact: Metal roofs are actually easier to maintain over time because they resist many of the issues that plague asphalt—like mold, cracking, or curling. When issues do arise, they’re usually isolated and easy to fix without replacing large sections.
That’s why it’s important to work with a qualified installer who specializes in metal roofing, not just general roofing services.
Don’t Let Myths Keep You from Making a Great Choice
Metal roofing myths have held back many homeowners from choosing a product that’s safer, longer-lasting, and more energy-efficient. The truth is, modern metal roof systems are engineered to meet the needs of today’s homes—especially in climates like Michigan’s.
With benefits ranging from hail resistance and energy savings to unmatched durability and modern design options, metal roofing is a proven investment. Don’t let outdated ideas keep you stuck with a roof that underperforms.
Why Homeowners Across Michigan Trust Big Rapids Roofing
At Big Rapids Roofing, we’ve helped hundreds of homeowners upgrade to metal roofing with confidence. Our team has the training, tools, and local experience to install systems that perform in every season.
What we offer:
- Certified metal roofing installers with product-specific training
- Custom standing seam and metal shingle options
- Fully licensed and insured local team
- Warrantied systems backed by premium manufacturers
- Detailed inspections and free consultations
We don’t rely on gimmicks or scare tactics—just clear information, honest pricing, and expert craftsmanship.
Ready to Learn More? Let’s Talk Metal.
If you’ve been weighing your roofing options and wondering if metal is right for your home, we’re here to help. We’ll answer your questions, show you real product samples, and walk you through the pros, cons, and pricing of each option.
Don’t wait until your current roof fails. Get a free estimate now and let Big Rapids Roofing show you what a well-built metal roof can do for your home.
